Post by She Rocks on Sept 4, 2006 11:57:53 GMT -5
They're down to the top 5 and only two more weeks of Supernova. We've all said anyone of the remaining rockers are capable singers. It's a matter of the bands feel and taste...
Well, after watching this weeks song writing clinic, neither Magni or Dilana showed much strength when it came to song writing. gilby even said..."It's a matter of what you can bring to the table. If you can't bring anything new to the band then why do we need you?".
And he's right. There really isn't a bad singer in the bunch but some just have more creativity and all around musicianship than the others.
Dilana admitted that she never thought song writing would be a big part of this. She came to be a singer and hasn't ever really written on her own. She really struggled with this task and uncovered a huge weakness.
Magni was another weak writer. Gilby expressed disappointment when having to help rewrite almost the whole thing.
Toby put together a melody and lyrics that Gilby couldn't find anything to improve upon.
Lukas came in with only one verse and chorus completed. true to lukas form...doing enough to just get by. What was there... was good but it wasn't complete. It was just lazy on his part.
Storm was the first one in and Gilby helped her rearrange the verse a little to give it a little uglier feel. After talking with Gilby they seemed to be on the same page. Gilby says he really likes her professionalism.
I think storm's the most well adjusted of all of the remaining contestants. She has the right mix of ego, seriousness but still having fun. I really like this chick...She was one of my favs in the beginning...then she kind of faded into the background for awhile...but she's really had some great performaces the past few weeks. And I think she's extremely likable (as is Lukas). I find myself pulling for her more and more every week. Although, I know she's not right for this band. I think she knows that too. She's got a career no matter what.
If they are going to have a top 3 finale, this means there must be a double elimination this week. I think it should be Magni and Dilana. Only because they aren't well rounded. both have amazing vocals...but this band needs more than a singer. They aren't strong enough writers to only need a great vocalist.
Now, I don't think it will be Magni and Dilana. I really think it's going to be Magni and Storm. They'll keep Dilana around for the final three. She's a fan favorite and it will help with the ratings for the finale.
I am not swayed by any of the conspiracy theories out there...
But the winner will be either Toby or Lukas. Which to me is disappointing...but it's my gut feel.
Well, after watching this weeks song writing clinic, neither Magni or Dilana showed much strength when it came to song writing. gilby even said..."It's a matter of what you can bring to the table. If you can't bring anything new to the band then why do we need you?".
And he's right. There really isn't a bad singer in the bunch but some just have more creativity and all around musicianship than the others.
Dilana admitted that she never thought song writing would be a big part of this. She came to be a singer and hasn't ever really written on her own. She really struggled with this task and uncovered a huge weakness.
Magni was another weak writer. Gilby expressed disappointment when having to help rewrite almost the whole thing.
Toby put together a melody and lyrics that Gilby couldn't find anything to improve upon.
Lukas came in with only one verse and chorus completed. true to lukas form...doing enough to just get by. What was there... was good but it wasn't complete. It was just lazy on his part.
Storm was the first one in and Gilby helped her rearrange the verse a little to give it a little uglier feel. After talking with Gilby they seemed to be on the same page. Gilby says he really likes her professionalism.
I think storm's the most well adjusted of all of the remaining contestants. She has the right mix of ego, seriousness but still having fun. I really like this chick...She was one of my favs in the beginning...then she kind of faded into the background for awhile...but she's really had some great performaces the past few weeks. And I think she's extremely likable (as is Lukas). I find myself pulling for her more and more every week. Although, I know she's not right for this band. I think she knows that too. She's got a career no matter what.
If they are going to have a top 3 finale, this means there must be a double elimination this week. I think it should be Magni and Dilana. Only because they aren't well rounded. both have amazing vocals...but this band needs more than a singer. They aren't strong enough writers to only need a great vocalist.
Now, I don't think it will be Magni and Dilana. I really think it's going to be Magni and Storm. They'll keep Dilana around for the final three. She's a fan favorite and it will help with the ratings for the finale.
I am not swayed by any of the conspiracy theories out there...
But the winner will be either Toby or Lukas. Which to me is disappointing...but it's my gut feel.