Post by daverocks on Aug 8, 2006 23:53:47 GMT -5
I must say the Rockstar Super Nova show is getting better as each show goes along.. even the bottom dwellers are improving.. although some still make me cringe.. I feel that Super Novas comments this week were leaning towards the Paula Abdul side and not the Simon Cowell stage that I support.. so anyway here are my views..
top group
1 Lucas -- did very well with Creep he has to thank Dilyana for suggesting he sing it..I am glad he got knocked down a notch last week.. he needs to lose some of the cockiness in order to maintain an edge..
2 Dilyana - also a great performance.. I feel Gilby playing with her didnt really enhance her performance she does well on her own.. but overall great... its a toss between her and Lucas
3- Toby - Talking Heads with an edge I thought he did a great job... Navarro did not like when he used the megaphone.. I thought it was great..
Middle group
4 - Ryan.. good performance although not as good as last week.. he still is holding his own
5- Storm - did a good We are the Champions.. I thought it was a good performance one of her best
6- Magni - I still am torn on how to rate him.. but he is worth sticking around for awhile.. a good performance not a great one..
the bottom dwellers..
7 - Patrice.. she just appears out of tune a little.. not a great performance but not a really bad one.. she is the top of the bottom..
8- Josh - Ok he is my candidate for top 3 definately.. he sang STP and he was way too high.. no balls in his voice.. and he was bobbing his head back and forth like he was singing Sugar Pie Honey Bunch intstead of a hard rock tune... time to go.. his days are numbered
9 - Jill - Super Nova said she did well.. I thought she was really really badly out of tune.. it was making me cry.. she probably will escape bottom 3 for her looks.. but she deserves to be in it..
10- Zaryia - why in the heck she is getting this far is amazing me.. she is starting to remind me of Manson.. all shock and awe.. I thought the outfit was kind of cool but thats the only positive I can find... she still cant sing and thats what this thing should be about..
thats it folks... someone comment on this... or at least tell me you are bored to death of reading such a long post.. later
top group
1 Lucas -- did very well with Creep he has to thank Dilyana for suggesting he sing it..I am glad he got knocked down a notch last week.. he needs to lose some of the cockiness in order to maintain an edge..
2 Dilyana - also a great performance.. I feel Gilby playing with her didnt really enhance her performance she does well on her own.. but overall great... its a toss between her and Lucas
3- Toby - Talking Heads with an edge I thought he did a great job... Navarro did not like when he used the megaphone.. I thought it was great..
Middle group
4 - Ryan.. good performance although not as good as last week.. he still is holding his own
5- Storm - did a good We are the Champions.. I thought it was a good performance one of her best
6- Magni - I still am torn on how to rate him.. but he is worth sticking around for awhile.. a good performance not a great one..
the bottom dwellers..
7 - Patrice.. she just appears out of tune a little.. not a great performance but not a really bad one.. she is the top of the bottom..
8- Josh - Ok he is my candidate for top 3 definately.. he sang STP and he was way too high.. no balls in his voice.. and he was bobbing his head back and forth like he was singing Sugar Pie Honey Bunch intstead of a hard rock tune... time to go.. his days are numbered
9 - Jill - Super Nova said she did well.. I thought she was really really badly out of tune.. it was making me cry.. she probably will escape bottom 3 for her looks.. but she deserves to be in it..
10- Zaryia - why in the heck she is getting this far is amazing me.. she is starting to remind me of Manson.. all shock and awe.. I thought the outfit was kind of cool but thats the only positive I can find... she still cant sing and thats what this thing should be about..
thats it folks... someone comment on this... or at least tell me you are bored to death of reading such a long post.. later